Examining Portrayals of Cognitive Dissonance in Cinema

Examining Cognitive Dissonance in Cinema

Cognitive dissonance refers to the mental discomfort felt when a person's beliefs or behaviors conflict with one another. This psychological phenomenon manifests in a variety of ways, both in real life and in fictional narratives. Many classic films provide insightful examples of cognitive dissonance at work. By analyzing characters and situations in movies through the lens of dissonance theory, we gain a deeper understanding of human psychology and storytelling.

What is Cognitive Dissonance?

First identified by psychologist Leon Festinger in the 1950s, cognitive dissonance occurs when a person experiences contradictory or inconsistent attitudes, beliefs, or behaviors. This creates mental tension and an unpleasant psychological state. To reduce this tension, people will often alter their thinking, beliefs, or actions to restore internal consistency and harmony.

Some key examples of cognitive dissonance include:

• Holding a fixed belief that is contradicted by new information or evidence
• Doing something that conflicts with one's moral values or sense of identity
• Wanting something but being unable to justify having it
• Making a difficult choice between two appealing options

Cognitive dissonance frequently arises in movie plots and character development, driving the narrative forward. Looking at examples in film provides insight into this common psychological experience.

Dissonance in Characters' Motivations and Values

One way cognitive dissonance manifests in movies is through characters making choices that seem to conflict with their professed motivations and values. For example:

• In Casablanca, Rick claims to be uninvolved politically but eventually joins the fight against the Nazis, conflicting with his neutrality.
• In The Godfather, Michael Corleone takes revenge and becomes a criminal boss, conflicting with his desire to be legitimately successful.
• In Gone Girl, Amy Elliott fabricates a rape story, conflicting with her feminism.

These contradictions between characters' actions, motivations, and values create dissonance. Viewers experience some of this dissonance themselves as they try to reconcile inconsistencies in the characters' psyches.

Dissonance from Difficult Choices

Many movie characters face difficult dilemmas that inevitably create cognitive dissonance. Having to choose between two options with downsides can conflict with their desires or values. Examples include:

• In Sophie's Choice, Sophie must choose which child lives, conflicting with her maternal instincts.
• In Million Dollar Baby, Frankie must decide whether to aid Maggie's wish to die, conflicting with his values.
• In The Dark Knight, Batman uses invasive surveillance, conflicting with his principles.

These no-win situations produce dissonance for both the characters and audience. We see characters wrestling with mental tension regarding their choices.

Dissonance from Inconsistency and Hypocrisy

Cognitive dissonance also arises when characters behave in ways inconsistent with their stated beliefs or past actions. For example:

• In American Beauty, a homophobic father harbors homosexual desires.
• In American Hustle, con artists struggle with gaining wealth through lying.
• In Mean Girls, gossiping "Plastics" demand others not gossip about them.

These hypocritical behaviors and personality inconsistencies generate mental discomfort. They also reflect real-life dissonance caused by our own hypocrisy.

Dissonance as Moral Awakening

Changes in a character's beliefs or actions over the course of a film narrative can also demonstrate cognitive dissonance. Often this represents a process of moral awakening. For instance:

• In Schindler's List, a greedy businessman undergoes a change of heart about Nazi oppression.
• In American History X, a racist skinhead renounces his prejudiced views in prison.
• In Beauty and the Beast, a spiteful prince transforms into a kinder person.

These transformations from "bad" to "good" reveal the thought processes people go through in overcoming dissonance and reevaluating their morals.

Dissonance in Audience Reactions

Interestingly, movies frequently produce cognitive dissonance in viewers themselves. Some ways include:

• Feeling discomfort about liking an immoral character
• Hoping for an outcome that contradicts our values
• Feeling surprised by our own strong reactions to events or characters
• Identifying with characters whose beliefs conflict with our own

These mixed emotions and inconsistencies between our attitudes, emotions, and identities as viewers also demonstrate the ubiquity of cognitive dissonance.

The Value of Studying Dissonance in Cinema

Looking at how cognitive dissonance manifests for both characters and audiences provides useful lessons about human psychology. It reveals our tendency to sometimes behave irrationally or in contradiction to our beliefs. Recognizing examples of dissonance can help us reflect on our own inconsistencies and thought processes. It reminds us that overcoming internal conflicts and reevaluating our motivations is part of moral and psychological growth. Studying the dramatization of dissonance in film ultimately makes us wiser about both storytelling and real life.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new treatment regimen.