Dayquil vs Alka Seltzer Plus: How to Choose the Right Cold Medicine
When you're knocked down with miserable cold and flu symptoms like cough, congestion, fever and body aches, you just want relief fast. Two popular over-the-counter options to help treat these symptoms are Dayquil and Alka Seltzer Plus.
But how do you know which one is right for your specific needs? While both can provide symptom relief, there are key differences between Dayquil and Alka Seltzer Plus in their active ingredients, dosage forms, and recommended uses.
Comparing Key Ingredients in Dayquil and Alka Seltzer Plus
To understand which medication may work better, it helps to look at their active ingredients:
Dayquil
- Acetaminophen - Pain and fever reducer
- Dextromethorphan - Cough suppressant
- Phenylephrine - Nasal decongestant
Alka Seltzer Plus
- Aspirin - Pain reliever, fever reducer
- Chlorpheniramine - Antihistamine for nasal congestion
- Dextromethorphan - Cough suppressant
- Phenylephrine - Nasal decongestant
So while both contain medications for cough, congestion and body aches, Alka Seltzer Plus also includes an antihistamine. This makes it more useful for allergy-related symptoms.
Forms and Dosage Differences
Dayquil and Alka Seltzer Plus also differ in their dosage forms:
- DayQuil - Liquid filled capsules taken every 4-6 hours.
- Alka Seltzer Plus - Effervescent tablets dissolved in water every 4 hours.
The liquids may be easier to swallow, especially if you have a sore throat. But the fizzing tablets can help break up chest congestion.
Speak to your doctor or pharmacist about the dosage amounts most suitable for your age and health status.
Intended Uses and Symptom Relief
In general, Dayquil is considered more effective for temporary relief of flu and cold symptoms like:
- Runny nose
- Nasal congestion
- Sneezing
- Cough
- Muscle aches
- Headache
- Fever
Whereas Alka Seltzer Plus Cold & Cough is marketed for relief of:
- Runny nose
- Nasal and sinus congestion
- Sneezing
- Watery eyes
- Itchy throat
- Coughing
- Aches, pains, and fever
So Alka Seltzer Plus may be the better choice if you are experiencing allergy symptoms like sinus pressure, watery eyes, and throat itching along with your cold.
How to Decide Between Dayquil and Alka Seltzer Plus
When trying to decide between Dayquil and Alka Seltzer Plus for your cold, here are some factors to consider:
Your Specific Symptoms
Assess your personal symptom profile. If you have nasal drainage, sinus pressure, and allergy symptoms, Alka Seltzer Plus may be more effective due to the added antihistamine. For just cough, congestion and body aches, Dayquil would provide sufficient relief.
Other Medications You Are Taking
Check whether your other current medications might interact with any ingredients in these cold formulas. For example, Dayquil contains acetaminophen so you don't want to double up with other sources of that. Alka Seltzer Plus contains aspirin which can interact with several medications.
Your Medical Conditions
Be aware of any health issues that could impact which medications are recommended for you. For instance, people with diabetes or on blood thinners should avoid products containing aspirin like Alka Seltzer Plus.
Pregnancy and Breastfeeding
Pregnant and nursing mothers should consult their doctor first, as some cold and flu medications contain ingredients like phenylephrine and dextromethorphan that may be contraindicated.
Flu vs. Cold Symptoms
Dayquil is designed for cold relief whereas Alka Seltzer Plus Severe Cold & Flu is marketed more for flu symptoms like higher fever, body aches, and chills. Assess whether your symptoms are flu-like or just a common cold.
Allergy Component
If your sniffles, sneezing, watery eyes, and sinus pressure are allergy-related, the antihistamine in Alka Seltzer Plus makes it a better option than regular Dayquil.
Duration of Symptoms
Keep in mind that over-the-counter cold medications are intended for temporary, short-term relief. If your symptoms last more than a few days, call your doctor.
Considering these key factors will help guide you to the best choice between these two popular cold remedies.
Combining Dayquil and Alka Seltzer Plus
For some people, taking DayQuil and Alka Seltzer Plus together may seem logical to cover all the bases. But combining multiple medications like this can be risky.
Here are some potential issues with taking both DayQuil and Alka Seltzer Plus at the same time:
- Increased risk of dangerous side effects
- Higher dosage of certain ingredients like dextromethorphan
- Multiple sources of the same active ingredient
- More medications than necessary for symptom relief
- Potential overmedication or overdose
- Medication interactions
Unless your doctor specifically advises otherwise, avoid doubling up on two different cold formulas. Stick to just DayQuil or Alka Seltzer Plus as directed on the package labeling.
Safe Use of Multiple Cold Medications
If you do need to take certain other individual cold medications in addition to DayQuil or Alka Seltzer Plus, here are some tips for safe use:
- Consult doctor about multiple cold meds together
- Ensure no ingredient overlaps or overdoses
- Limit combinations to recommended time periods
- Follow all dosage guidelines carefully
- Stop immediately if side effects develop
- Avoid combinations if you are very drowsy
Your pharmacist can also advise if layering on other cold symptom relievers is appropriate based on your health profile and current medications.
Comparing Side Effects of Dayquil and Alka Seltzer Plus
All medications can potentially cause side effects. Here is a comparison of the common side effects reported with Dayquil vs Alka Seltzer Plus:
Dayquil Possible Side Effects
- Drowsiness
- Dizziness
- Nausea
- Stomach upset
- Vomiting
- Loss of appetite
- Anxiety
- Trouble sleeping
Alka Seltzer Plus Possible Side Effects
- Drowsiness
- Dizziness
- Excitability
- Stomach upset
- Nausea
- Vomiting
- Rash
- Tightness in chest
- Ringing in ears
As you can see, both share common side effects like stomach upset, nausea, and drowsiness. Alka Seltzer Plus also poses risks like rash, chest tightness, and ringing ears not seen with Dayquil.
Tell your doctor right away if any concerning or serious side effects develop when taking either medication.
Safely Managing Side Effects
To help prevent potential side effects when taking DayQuil or Alka Seltzer Plus, you can:
- Take with food to reduce stomach upset
- Stay hydrated and drink fluids
- Avoid driving or hazards if drowsy
- Avoid alcohol while medicated
- Follow dosage recommendations
- Tell doctor about any reactions
Being aware of the possible side effects and using care when taking these cold medications can help minimize risks.
Who Should Not Take Dayquil or Alka Seltzer Plus?
While Dayquil and Alka Seltzer Plus are sold over-the-counter, they are not suitable for everyone with a cold or flu. You should avoid these products if:
- You have an allergy to any ingredients
- You take antidepressants or MAO inhibitors
- You have diabetes or digestive ulcers (Alka Seltzer Plus only)
- You take prescription blood thinners like warfarin
- You have liver disease or glaucoma
- You have high blood pressure (Alka Seltzer Plus only)
- You are pregnant or breastfeeding
Alka Seltzer Plus also contains aspirin, so should be avoided by children or teens with flu symptoms due to risk of Reye's syndrome.
When in doubt, consult with your pharmacist or health care provider before taking these medications if you have medical conditions or take other drugs.
Home Remedies as Alternatives for Colds and Flu
While medications like Dayquil and Alka Seltzer Plus can provide symptom relief for colds and flu, some people may prefer more natural alternatives. Here are some options:
Hot Beverages
Sipping on hot tea with honey or lemon can help soothe a sore throat and break up mucus. Broths provide hydration during illness. Adding garlic, ginger or turmeric may offer added benefits.Steam and Humidifiers
Inhaling steam from a hot shower or boiled pot of water can open up nasal passages and make breathing easier. Running a humidifier can also moisten and relieve dry irritated airways.Saltwater Gargle and Rinse
Gargling with warm salt water can coat a sore irritable throat. Saline nasal rinses can also flush mucus and germs from nasal passages.Zinc and Vitamin C
Supplements containing zinc, vitamin C, and other immune supporting nutrients may help shorten duration and severity. Look for lozenges or powdered mixes.Chicken Soup
Warm brothy chicken noodle soup can both hydrate and offer nourishment during illness. The steam may help clear nasal congestion as well.Honey
Honey has antimicrobial and soothing properties. Try adding it to lemon water, tea, or even take tablespoons for a cough suppressing effect. Just avoid in infants.Ask your doctor if trying any natural cold and flu remedies are appropriate based on your health status and symptoms.
When to See a Doctor for Colds and Flu
While Dayquil, Alka Seltzer Plus and natural remedies can help provide relief for mild cold and flu symptoms, it's important to see a doctor if you experience:
- Fever above 101 F that won't lower
- Symptoms lasting more than 10 days
- Wheezing, chest pain, or difficulty breathing
- Thick yellow or green mucus
- Ear pain
- Stiff neck
- Rash
- Severe body aches, chills, or fatigue
- Sinus pain or tenderness
Seeking medical treatment promptly is especially crucial for those at high risk like infants, elderly, pregnant women, and immunocompromised patients.
Your doctor can evaluate your symptoms, provide prescriptions if needed for bacterial infections, recommend over-the-counter medications appropriate for your health status, or offer guidance on finding relief.
The Bottom Line - Choosing Between Dayquil and Alka Seltzer Plus
When it comes to picking an over-the-counter medication for cold and flu relief, both Dayquil and Alka Seltzer Plus can be effective options. DayQuil offers targeted symptom relief for issues like cough, congestion and body aches. Alka Seltzer Plus Cold & Cough provides added relief for allergy-related symptoms as well.
Consider your specific symptom profile, medical conditions, other medications, and duration of illness. For multi-symptom relief, opt for Alka Seltzer Plus Cold & Flu with its antihistamine component. Go for DayQuil Severe for just common cold symptoms. But avoid combining both formulations together.
Use smartly, follow all dosage guidelines, and see a doctor if symptoms are severe, persist, or are accompanied by complications. With the right medication choice, you can help find temporary relief when colds or flu have you under the weather.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new treatment regimen.
Add Comment