Can You Mix Tretinoin With Niacinamide?
Tretinoin and niacinamide are both popular ingredients used in skincare products. Tretinoin, also known as retinoic acid, is a topical retinoid commonly prescribed to treat acne and reduce signs of aging. Niacinamide, also known as vitamin B3, is an antioxidant that can help brighten skin, improve texture, and strengthen the skin barrier.
While both tretinoin and niacinamide offer various skin benefits, there has been some debate over whether these two ingredients can be safely used together in the same skincare routine. Some people claim that mixing tretinoin and niacinamide causes flushing, breakouts, and irritation. However, recent research and guidance from dermatologists suggest that these two ingredients are likely compatible for most skin types when used properly.
Examining the Evidence on Mixing Tretinoin and Niacinamide
Early skincare advice suggested avoiding layering tretinoin and niacinamide together due to concerns that the niacinamide could potentially convert to niacin in the presence of the retinoid, causing skin flushing. However, several recent studies have challenged this notion and found no evidence of conversion or flushing when the two ingredients are combined.
For example, a 2005 study published in the Journal of Cosmetic Dermatology examined the interaction between tretinoin, niacinamide, and sunscreen. The researchers found that mixing 5% niacinamide gel with 0.025% tretinoin cream did not result in any niacin-induced skin flushing or irritation. They concluded that niacinamide and tretinoin can safely be combined in cosmetic products and effectively deliver skin benefits.
Additionally, a 2018 review published in the Journal of Drugs in Dermatology analyzed prior research on combining tretinoin and niacinamide. The authors highlighted that earlier in vitro studies showing conversion from niacinamide to niacin used unrealistically acidic pH levels far from normal skin conditions. They concluded current evidence does not support concerns about using tretinoin and niacinamide together.
Dermatologist Recommendations on Mixing Tretinoin and Niacinamide
In addition to recent studies, many dermatologists also support combining tretinoin and niacinamide in a skincare routine when introduced properly. Here are some tips from dermatologists on safely using tretinoin and niacinamide together:
- Introduce one active ingredient at a time. Using both tretinoin and niacinamide at the same time can increase irritation for some skin types. Start with one product for a few weeks before adding the other.
- Use niacinamide in the morning, tretinoin at night. Splitting up the ingredients by time of day reduces risk of irritation.
- Apply niacinamide before tretinoin. Some derms recommend layering niacinamide under tretinoin when using one right after the other.
- Use a moisturizer. Hydrating the skin properly can minimize potential irritation from the ingredients.
- Start with lower percentages. Opt for lower concentrations like 0.025% tretinoin and 5% niacinamide to better tolerate the combination.
- Monitor skin reaction. Discontinue use if you experience excessive redness, peeling, itching or breakouts.
Overall, most dermatologists agree that tretinoin and niacinamide are likely compatible and beneficial together for those with resilient skin. However, those with highly sensitive skin may still need to exercise caution when combining the ingredients.
Benefits of Using Tretinoin and Niacinamide Together
When layered properly in a skincare regimen, tretinoin and niacinamide can offer complementary benefits:
- Acne treatment: Tretinoin clears pores and reduces acne while niacinamide decreases inflammation.
- Brightening effects: Niacinamide evens skin tone as tretinoin increases new collagen.
- Anti-aging: Tretinoin reduces fine lines and wrinkles while niacinamide strengthens the moisture barrier.
- Improved texture: Both ingredients refine skin texture and smooth roughness.
Additionally, some research suggests that combining tretinoin and niacinamide may offer added advantages compared to using either active alone. One study found cosmetic formulations with both tretinoin and niacinamide improved fine lines, hyperpigmentation, elasticity, and skin yellowing after 8 weeks better than preparations with just one of the actives.
How to Combine Tretinoin and Niacinamide in Your Routine
If you want to reap the combined potential benefits of tretinoin and niacinamide, here are some tips on how to safely and effectively use them together:
- Use niacinamide in the morning after cleansing, before heavier creams.
- Apply tretinoin at night, after water-based serums but before moisturizer.
- Include a gentle cleanser and lightweight moisturizer, like a gel cream, in your routine.
- Exfoliate 1-2 times per week max to avoid irritation.
- Always use a broad spectrum sunscreen during daytime with tretinoin.
- Consider adding other soothing ingredients like green tea, aloe, or ceramides.
- Start by using tretinoin and niacinamide on alternating nights.
- Gradually work up to using them together, monitoring for increased dryness or irritation.
An example routine could be:
AM:- Gentle cleanser
- Niacinamide serum
- Light moisturizer
- Sunscreen
- Gentle cleanser
- Tretinoin
- Soothing gel cream
Signs Tretinoin and Niacinamide May Not be Compatible for You
While most evidence indicates tretinoin and niacinamide are safe to combine for many skin types, pay attention for the following signs the combination may be too harsh for your skin:
- Increased redness and irritation
- Dry, flaky, peeling skin
- Itching or stinging after application
- New breakouts or acne after starting combination
If you experience any of these effects, try alternating the ingredients at different times of day. You can also reduce application frequency of one active or the other to 2-3 times per week max. If skin irritation continues, consider stopping use of one product temporarily.
Who May Want to Avoid Combining Tretinoin and Niacinamide
While current evidence indicates tretinoin and niacinamide are well-tolerated when layered properly, some individuals may be better off avoiding use of the ingredients together, including:
- Sensitive skin: Those prone to irritation or dermatitis may experience excessive redness and flaking from the combination.
- Eczema or rosacea: The ingredients could further aggravate and worsen these inflammatory skin conditions for some people.
- Very dry skin: People prone to dryness and flaking may find both actives overly drying used together.
- Damaged moisture barrier: Compromised, cracked skin needs time to heal before adding these actives.
- Skin of color: Higher risk of post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation from irritation makes cautious use important.
Those with any of the above skin types or conditions may see better results by using tretinoin and niacinamide separately at different times rather than layered together.
FAQs
Can I use tretinoin and niacinamide together at the same time?
It's generally recommended to use tretinoin and niacinamide at different times - niacinamide in the morning and tretinoin at night. Using both actives simultaneously increases the risk of irritation for some skin types.
What percentage of tretinoin and niacinamide can I safely combine?
Start with lower concentrations like 0.025% tretinoin and 5% niacinamide. Higher percentages may cause excessive dryness and peeling when used together.
Should I apply niacinamide before or after tretinoin?
Apply niacinamide before heavier creams like tretinoin. Some derms recommend layering niacinamide under tretinoin when using one right after the other.
Can I use other actives with tretinoin and niacinamide?
It's best to avoid using multiple potentially irritating actives together. Use other ingredients like vitamin C, AHA's, or benzoyl peroxide separately from tretinoin and niacinamide.
What signs mean I should stop combining tretinoin and niacinamide?
Discontinue use if you experience increased irritation like redness, peeling, itching or new breakouts after starting the combination.
Add Comment