Turnip Greens vs Spinach - How Do They Compare?
When it comes to leafy greens, turnip greens and spinach are both powerhouses packed with vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants. But is one healthier than the other? Understanding the similarities and differences helps you get the maximum nutritional benefits.
Turnip greens come from the leafy tops of turnips, a root vegetable closely related to broccoli and kale. Spinach is well known as a super healthy green that can be eaten fresh or cooked. Both provide key nutrients, but offer their own unique health perks.
Keep reading for a detailed comparison of turnip greens versus spinach to help you decide which is best for your diet.
Nutrition Profile
Turnip greens and spinach have the following macro and micronutrient profiles in a 1 cup cooked serving:
Turnip Greens (Chopped)
- Calories: 18
- Fat: 0.2g
- Carbs: 3.8g
- Fiber: 2.3g
- Protein: 1.5g
- Vitamin A: 278% DV
- Vitamin C: 65% DV
- Vitamin K: 573% DV
- Magnesium: 5% DV
- Potassium: 12% DV
Spinach (Chopped, Cooked)
- Calories: 41
- Fat: 0.5g
- Carbs: 7g
- Fiber: 4g
- Protein: 5g
- Vitamin A: 418% DV
- Vitamin C: 27% DV
- Vitamin K: 987% DV
- Magnesium: 23% DV
- Potassium: 17% DV
Both greens are extremely low in calories, fat, and carbs while providing essential vitamins and minerals. Spinach has a slightly better nutrition profile with more protein, fiber, vitamins A and K, magnesium and potassium.
Beneficial Compounds
In addition to basic nutrition stats, turnip greens and spinach contain beneficial plant compounds linked to health benefits:
Turnip Greens
- Glucosinolates - anticancer properties
- Quercetin - antioxidant that reduces inflammation
- Kaempferol - antioxidant that protects heart health
- Lutein - antioxidant that benefits eye health
- Zeaxanthin - maintains eye and vision health
Spinach
- Lutein - critical for eye and vision health
- Zeaxanthin - protects eyes from UV light damage
- Quercetin - anti-inflammatory flavonoid
- Kaempferol - lowers oxidative stress and inflammation
- Nitrates - improve circulation and lower blood pressure
Both turnip greens and spinach deliver lutein and zeaxanthin. Spinach contains more lutein, while turnip greens provide special compounds like glucosinolates with cancer-fighting abilities.
Vitamins & Minerals
Here is how the vitamin and mineral content in turnip greens versus spinach compares:
Vitamin A
Spinach has significantly more vitamin A. One cup provides over 400% of the daily recommended value, compared to 278% in turnip greens.
Vitamin C
Turnip greens edge out spinach when it comes to vitamin C content. Turnips offer 65% DV per serving, while spinach has around half that amount.
Vitamin K
Spinach is one of the best sources of vitamin K, with almost 1000% DV per cup. Turnip greens trail behind at 573% DV.
Folate
Spinach wins for folate content. It supplies around 50% DV, while turnip greens offer about 15% DV.
Magnesium
You'll get nearly 25% of your daily magnesium needs from spinach compared to only 5% from turnips.
Potassium
Both greens provide potassium, but spinach contains slightly higher amounts with 17% DV versus 12% DV in turnip greens.
For the most part, spinach boasts higher levels of vitamins and minerals. But turnip greens make up for it with unique beneficial plant compounds.
Antioxidants
Antioxidants protect against oxidative stress and inflammation driving chronic diseases. Here is how the antioxidant profiles compare:
Turnip Greens
The antioxidant capacity of turnip greens measures 17409 TE/100g. They contain flavonoid antioxidants like quercetin, kaempferol, and hydroxycinnamic acid.
Spinach
Spinach has an antioxidant score of 15940 TE/100g, slightly lower than turnips. It is high in flavonoid antioxidants like quercetin and kaempferol.
Both greens are antioxidant powerhouses. Turnip greens seem to possess slightly stronger overall antioxidant abilities.
Anti-Inflammatory Effects
Chronic inflammation contributes to conditions like heart disease, diabetes, and cancer. Turnips and spinach both provide anti-inflammatory benefits:
Turnip Greens
The antioxidants in turnip greens combat inflammation. Their glucosinolates and isothiocyanates also have anti-inflammatory effects.
Spinach
Spinach contains unique anti-inflammatory compounds like methylenedioxyflavonol glucuronides. Its lutein also reduces inflammation.
Both greens rank as excellent anti-inflammatory foods making them helpful for preventing or reducing inflammatory diseases.
Vision & Eye Health
The carotenoids lutein and zeaxanthin found in turnip greens and spinach promote eye and vision health:
Turnip Greens
Turnip greens are a good source of lutein and zeaxanthin. These compounds accumulate in the eyes and filter harmful blue light.
Spinach
With over 20 mg of lutein per cup, spinach is one of the world's best sources. It also contains zeaxanthin which protects the eyes from UV damage.
For maximum eye health benefits, spinach appears to have a slight edge over turnip greens.
Heart Health
Here is how turnips and spinach influence cardiovascular health:
Turnip Greens
With lots of vitamin K, turnip greens help prevent calcium deposits in arteries to reduce heart disease risks. The antioxidants also protect heart health.
Spinach
Spinach's nutrients improve blood pressure, lower oxidative stress, and decrease arterial stiffness for better heart health. The nitrates boost circulation.
Both greens promote heart health through different mechanisms. Incorporating both makes a smart heart-healthy strategy.
Cancer Prevention
Research shows turnip greens and spinach may help fight cancer development and growth:
Turnip Greens
The glucosinolates in turnip greens display powerful anticancer activities. Isothiocyanates prevent cancer cell proliferation and trigger cell death.
Spinach
The carotenoids in spinach like lutein and zeaxanthin show promise against breast, lung, and prostate cancers. Folate may help prevent colon cancer.
Turnip greens seem to have greater cancer-fighting abilities, particularly against lung and stomach cancers.
Digestive Health
Both greens benefit digestive health, but in different ways:
Turnip Greens
Turnip greens are high in fiber, which promotes regularity and healthy gut bacteria. Their glucosinolates also deter growth of bad bacteria.
Spinach
Spinach contains a digestive carotenoid called luteolin that has prebiotic effects. This compound stimulates growth of beneficial bifidobacteria.
The two greens support gut health through different mechanisms. Combining both ensures comprehensive digestive benefits.
Adverse Effects
Turnip greens and spinach are extremely healthy, but a few things to be aware of:
Turnip Greens
- Goitrogens may impact thyroid function if consumed in excess.
- High in vitamin K which could interact with blood thinners.
- Oxalates may cause kidney stones in sensitive people.
Spinach
- Spinach is high in oxalates which can lead to kidney stones.
- Purines in spinach may exacerbate gout symptoms.
- Nutrients can be diminished from overcooking spinach.
Both contain oxalates and vitamin K in high amounts, so people with kidney issues or on blood thinners should exercise caution.
Key Differences Between Turnip Greens and Spinach
To recap the major differences:
- Spinach has more protein, fiber, vitamins A and K, magnesium, and potassium.
- Turnip greens contain more vitamin C and unique glucosinolates.
- Spinach has higher lutein levels while turnips have more varied antioxidants.
- Turnip greens show greater anticancer abilities.
- Spinach benefits eye health and circulation more.
While spinach wins out in several nutritional categories, turnip greens offer their own set of distinct health advantages. Incorporating both provides a diverse range of nutrients, antioxidants, and plant compounds.
Should You Choose Turnip Greens or Spinach?
When comparing turnip greens versus spinach, there is no clear winner. Both greens bring stellar nutrition to the table along with proven health benefits.
Spinach shines for its extremely high amounts of vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants like lutein. It supports heart health, vision, and much more.
However, turnip greens boast unique beneficial plant compounds called glucosinolates. These show promise against cancer, bacteria, inflammation, and offer different antioxidants than spinach.
For maximum nutrition and health value, there is no need to choose between the two greens. Incorporate both turnip greens and spinach into a balanced diet regularly for their stellar nutrient profiles and wide range of benefits.
Together, they help combat disease, support healthy aging, reduce inflammation, protect your eyesight, and so much more. Switch up cooking methods like sauteeing, steaming, or adding them to soups, salads, and smoothies.
So don't pick just one winner. Make room on your plate for both turnip greens and spinach to enhance your diet and overall health!
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new treatment regimen.
Add Comment