Best Bark Collar Reviews and Buyer's Guide

What Is a Bark Collar?

A bark collar is a training device that is worn by dogs that bark excessively or unnecessarily. The collar delivers a negative stimulus when the dog barks in order to deter and reduce barking over time. There are several types of bark collars available that use different methods to curb barking such as a spray collar that emits citronella spray, a vibration collar that vibrates when barking is detected, and a static shock collar that gives a shock. While controversial, many dog owners have found success using bark collars to control excessive vocalization in their pets.

How Does a Bark Collar Work?

A bark collar has a microphone to pick up the sound of a dog's bark. When barking is detected, the collar provides an aversive stimulus, usually in the form of a spray, vibration, or static shock. The stimulus startles the dog and interrupts the barking. Over time, the dog associates barking with the unpleasant stimulus and begins to avoid barking unnecessarily in order to prevent activation of the collar. The stimulus level on most bark collars can be adjusted to suit each dog's sensitivity level. Some collars have a safety feature that stops activation after a certain number of corrections to prevent over-correction.

Types of Bark Collars

There are several types of bark collars available. Here are some of the most common:

• Spray Collars - Emits a burst of citronella spray when barking is detected. The unpleasant odor helps curb barking.
• Vibration Collars - Utilizes vibrations similar to a cell phone to interrupt barking patterns.
• Static Shock Collars - Delivers a mild static shock when activated by barking. Considered more aversive than other collars.
• Ultrasonic Collars - Emits a high frequency sound only detectable by dogs to deter barking.
• Unscented Spray Collars - Uses an unscented spray instead of citronella to correct barking behavior.

Pros of Bark Collars

When used properly, there are several advantages to using a bark collar:

• Effectively reduce excessive barking and vocalization
• Can be used when owners are away or not present
• Help avoid nuisance complaints from neighbors
• Prevent dogs from barking themselves hoarse
• Customizable correction levels suit each dog's needs
• Collar vibrations get dog's attention without startling them
• Citronella spray collars use natural oils and are dog-safe
• Some units are waterproof for outdoor use

Cons of Bark Collars

However, there are also some potential drawbacks to consider with bark collars:

• Does not address root cause of barking behavior
• Could lead to other anxiety-related behaviors
• Punishment can suppress personality and enthusiasm
• Citronella spray smell may linger on dog's fur
• Static shock collars considered inhumane by some
• Dogs may ignore spray or vibration after getting used to it
• Collars require proper fit and placement to work
• Not a good option for dogs under 6 months old

How to Choose the Best Bark Collar

Choosing the right bark collar for your dog takes some consideration. Here are some tips for selecting the most effective and humane bark collar:

Match Collar Type to Temperament

Take your dog's personality into account. Milder collars like citronella spray or vibration work best for dogs that are startled easily. More stubborn barkers may require a stronger deterrent like unscented spray or static shock.

Do Not Overcorrect

Too much stimulation from a bark collar can lead to increased anxiety in dogs. Collars that limit the number of corrections are safest. Only leave the collar on during problem barking times.

Proper Fit

Ensuring the collar fits snugly against the dog's neck guarantees barking is accurately detected. A loose fit can lead to accidental corrections. Consider having a professional fit the collar.

For Home Use Only

Bark collars are intended for use in your home environment only. Do not keep a bark collar on your dog when taking them for walks or to public places.

Observe Your Dog

When first using a bark collar, stay close by to monitor your dog's reaction. Stop use if you observe signs of distress or anxiety.

Use Intermittently

Rather than having your dog wear the collar consistently, use it intermittently over a training period of several weeks. This prevents habituation while still reducing barking.

Positively Reinforce Quiet

When your dog abstains from barking, be sure to praise and reward the quiet behavior. This creates a positive association with not barking.

Top Rated Bark Collars

Based on effectiveness, safety features, and customer satisfaction, here are 5 of the best bark collar options:

SportDOG NoBark SBC-R Rechargeable Bark Collar

This collar uses both vibration and static stimulation to deter barking. It has 10 levels of static shock correction and a safety shut-off after 80 seconds of barking. The collar is waterproof, rechargeable, and good for dogs 8 pounds and up.

Garmin Bark Limiter Deluxe

With a range of up to 900 feet, this bark collar can be used anywhere in your home or yard. It has adjustable levels of vibration and static shock correction. A battery light indicates when to recharge the lithium-ion battery that lasts around 2 months.

PetSafe Elite Little Dog Bark Collar

Designed for small dogs over 5 pounds, this spray bark collar emits citronella with each bark to startle and deter vocalization. Battery life lasts around 3 months and the collar has a low tank indicator light.

Petrageous Wi-Fi Smart Bark Collar

Connect this bark collar to your home WiFi for app control and barking alerts. Choose from audible alarm, vibration, or static shock modes. For dogs 5 pounds and over, the collar corrects up to 9 barks in a minute.

Casfuy Bark Collar with Temperament Learning

Using AI technology, this collar "learns" your dog's barking patterns to deliver customized corrections. It combines vibration, static shock, and sound effects based on the dog's unique temperament. Fits neck sizes from 8 to 26 inches.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are bark collars safe for dogs?

Yes, bark collars are safe when used properly and not overused. Choose a collar with safety features to avoid over-correcting. Never leave the collar on for extended periods of time unsupervised.

When should you not use a bark collar?

Avoid bark collars on aggressive dogs, elderly dogs, sick dogs, dogs under 6 months old, and for prolonged periods. They are not a substitute for training, only a reinforcement aid.

Do bark collars work for all dogs?

Most dogs will respond to bark collars with proper introduction. However, some dogs can become accustomed to the stimulus, ignoring it. Using random reinforcement schedules and consistent training helps prevent this.

Where is the best place to put a bark collar?

Bark collars work best when fitted high on the dog's neck near the base of the skull. Ensure you can fit a finger between the collar and neck. Check fit regularly as neck size can change.

Can bark collars be used for more than one dog?

Yes, bark collars can be interchangeably used between multiple dogs in the same home. Make sure to adjust fit accordingly and watch each dog's reaction closely when first implementing the collar.

The Bottom Line

When attempting to curtail nuisance barking, a quality bark collar is an effective training tool for many dogs. Keep in mind that bark collars should never be used long term or as stand-alone solutions. Always pair the collar with positive reinforcement of quiet behavior. With patience and consistency, both owners and dogs benefit from reduced barking and a more peaceful environment.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new treatment regimen.