Introduction
Green tea and matcha have become incredibly popular in recent years, and for good reason. Both are packed with health-promoting compounds like antioxidants and have been associated with a variety of benefits, ranging from increased fat burning to reduced risk of heart disease and diabetes.
But while green tea and matcha both come from the same plant, they are slightly different and each has their own set of advantages and disadvantages. This article will compare green tea vs matcha to help you determine which one may be best for you.
What is Green Tea?
Green tea is a type of tea made solely from the leaves of the Camellia sinensis plant. It undergoes minimal oxidation during processing, which helps preserve many of its beneficial compounds.
The tea leaves are first harvested, withered to reduce moisture content, and then very lightly steamed or pan-fired to inactivate enzymes and prevent too much oxidation. After rolling and drying the leaves again, the final loose-leaf green tea product is ready for packaging.
To brew green tea, the dried tea leaves are steeped in hot water for two to three minutes before drinking. This allows the flavor and nutrients to infuse into the water.
Benefits of Green Tea
Here are some of the top evidence-based health benefits associated with drinking green tea:
- May increase fat burning and boost metabolic rate
- Contains potent antioxidants like epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG)
- May protect brain health and improve memory
- Linked to lower risk of heart disease, stroke, and diabetes
- May reduce risk of cancer
- May improve dental health and reduce bad breath
Studies show that the compounds found in green tea, especially EGCG, can have powerful biological effects on the body. The key is to optimize your intake by choosing high-quality tea and brewing it correctly to maximize the extraction of these health-promoting nutrients.
What is Matcha?
Matcha comes from the same Camellia sinensis plant as green tea, but it undergoes a different processing method. To produce matcha, the tea leaves are first shade-grown for three to four weeks before harvest. This increases production of chlorophyll, amino acids, and L-Theanine.
After picking, the leaves go through stemmed, deveined, and stone ground into a fine powder. Unlike loose leaf tea, matcha powder can be whisked directly into water for consumption.
Because the entire tea leaf is ingested, matcha offers higher concentrations of many nutrients than steeped green tea. It also has a richer flavor and smoother, creamier texture.
Benefits of Matcha
As with green tea, matcha has been linked to an array of health benefits. Here are some of the top evidence-based ways that matcha may benefit health:
- Packed with antioxidants like EGCG
- May support brain function and protect neurons
- Contains amino acid L-theanine, which promotes relaxation
- Provides chlorophyll, vitamins, minerals, and fiber
- May increase energy, endurance, and fat metabolism
- Linked to reduced risk of heart disease, diabetes, and cancer
Research has found that matcha has even higher antioxidant activity than regular green tea. The combination of polyphenols, catechins, and amino acids may be responsible for its many purported benefits.
Differences Between Green Tea and Matcha
So what sets green tea and matcha apart? Here are a few of the main differences between green tea vs matcha:
Processing
Green tea is made from steaming, firing, and drying the tea leaves, while matcha undergoes a special shading process and the leaves are ground into powder.
Form
Green tea is prepared from loose tea leaves, while matcha powder is whisked directly into hot water before drinking.
Flavor
Matcha tends to have a richer, smoother flavor compared to the light grassiness of green tea.
Caffeine Content
Matcha has a bit more caffeine than green tea, with around 70mg per serving compared to 35-45mg.
Antioxidants
Because you ingest the whole tea leaf, matcha generally contains higher levels of antioxidants like EGCG.
Preparation
Green tea takes 2-3 minutes to steep while matcha is whisked and consumed immediately.
Cost
High-quality matcha is typically more expensive than loose-leaf green tea.
Green Tea vs Matcha Nutrition
Both green tea and matcha are nutritionally dense beverages filled with important compounds and micronutrients.
However, matcha tends to be higher in certain compounds thanks to the special cultivation and processing methods used. Heres an overview of the nutrition of green tea versus matcha:
Antioxidants
Both are excellent sources antioxidants, including polyphenols like catechins and EGCG. Matcha is generally higher in antioxidants than green tea.
Caffeine
Green tea contains 35-45mg caffeine per eight ounce cup, while matcha has about 70mg. However, this can vary based on factors like the quality and how it is prepared.
Amino Acids
Matcha is especially high in amino acids like L-theanine, which promotes relaxation, focus, and alertness.
Vitamins & Minerals
Both contain small amounts of B vitamins, vitamin C, selenium, chromium, and zinc.
Chlorophyll
With matcha, you ingest the whole tea leaf, providing higher levels of chlorophyll than green tea.
Fiber
Drinking matcha can add about one gram of fiber per one teaspoon (two grams) serving.
Health Benefits
Studies have found that both green tea and matcha are associated with an impressive list of health benefits. However, matcha has been shown to have even more powerful effects when it comes to metabolism, calming effects, cancer prevention, and antioxidant activity.
Metabolism
Research shows that green tea can give metabolism a mild boost, increasing fat burning by about 4%. Matcha has been found to ramp up thermogenesis even more, enhancing the metabolism by up to 43% for several hours after consuming it.
Cancer Prevention
The potent antioxidants in both green tea and matcha have been tied to a reduced risk of cancer. Matcha may be especially protective, with some studies finding that it could reduce the growth and spread of cancer cells.
Heart Health
Both have been associated with a lower risk of heart disease and stroke, thanks to their ability to reduce blood pressure, cholesterol levels, and inflammation.
Relaxation
L-theanine in matcha produces a calming effect by increasing alpha waves in the brain. Green tea contains much less theanine to support relaxation.
Cognitive Function
The amino acids in matcha may improve concentration, memory, and reaction time. More research is needed on green tea and brain health.
Antioxidant Content
Matcha has been shown to have up to 137 times more antioxidants than low-grade green tea. The polyphenols in matcha exhibit strong antioxidant activities to prevent cell damage.
How to Use Green Tea vs Matcha
So should you be sipping green tea or whisking up matcha? Heres a quick overview of how to use each one:
Green Tea
To make green tea, add one teaspoon of loose tea leaves per cup of hot water and steep for two to three minutes. You can also adjust the quantity of tea leaves and steeping time to modulate the flavor and strength.
Look for high-quality, loose-leaf tea to get the most health benefits. Green tea bags often contain poor-quality, crushed tea leaves.
You can also brew green tea at lower temperatures (around 160F vs 212F for matcha) for a more delicate, less astringent flavor.
Matcha
With matcha, youll mix one to two teaspoons of powder with two ounces hot water until frothy using a bamboo whisk or milk frother. You can adjust the ratio of powder to water to achieve your preferred consistency and strength.
Opt for ceremonial-grade or high-quality matcha for the best flavor and nutrient profile. Note that because you consume the whole leaf, its important to buy organic to avoid pesticide exposure.
Matcha can also be combined into smoothies, lattes, desserts, and more to boost the antioxidant content of your favorite foods and drinks.
Downsides of Green Tea vs Matcha
Both green tea and matcha are highly nutritious and associated with an array of health benefits. However, there are some potential downsides to consider as well:
Green Tea
- Contains lower amounts of certain compounds
- More delicate flavor
- May become bitter if steeped too long
- Caffeine content can cause side effects in sensitive people
- Contains fluoride
Matcha
- More expensive
- Higher in caffeine
- Can be bitter if low-quality
- Must be whisked/stirred
- Higher in lead than green tea
Both also contain small amounts of oxalates, which can contribute to kidney stones in those prone to them. Additionally, both are acidic and could erode tooth enamel over time.
FAQ
Is matcha just ground up green tea?
Matcha is made from green tea leaves that are specially grown and processed to maximize nutrient levels. The green tea plants are covered for shade growing, hand-picked, stemmed and deveined, then stone-grounded into a fine powder.
Is matcha healthier than green tea?
Matcha is considered more nutrient-dense and has higher levels of compounds like amino acids, polyphenols, and antioxidants. However, both offer an array of health benefits.
Does matcha have more or less caffeine than coffee?
Matcha contains around 70mg caffeine per serving compared to 95mg in eight ounces of coffee. So coffee has a bit more, but matcha still provides a moderate caffeine boost.
Is matcha good for weight loss?
Some research has found that matcha could help boost metabolism and increase fat burning compared to green tea, potentially aiding weight loss. However, more studies are needed.
The Bottom Line
So in the debate of green tea versus matcha, is one better than the other? Both offer unique nutritional profiles and are brimming with health benefits. Matcha is higher in certain compounds, but green tea is more affordable and still provides an impressive nutrient punch.
Including either green tea or matcha in your diet could support better health. But matcha may be the better choice if youre looking to increase antioxidant intake, relax, or give your metabolism a stronger boost.
As with any supplement, its best to stick to moderate intake and rotate between the two to maximize the benefits of both beverages.
Drink your matcha latte one day, then switch to green tea the next to hedge your bets. This ensures you get the best of both worlds when it comes to health-promoting compounds and smart caffeine consumption.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new treatment regimen.
Add Comment