Are Pumpernickel Bagels Healthy for People With Diabetes?
For people with diabetes, choosing healthy foods that won't spike blood sugar levels is crucial. The type of bread they eat can have a big impact on blood sugar control. So an important question for many is: are pumpernickel bagels a good option?
Pumpernickel bread is a dark, dense rye bread made with coarsely ground rye. It has a rich color and distinctively tangy taste. Bagels made from pumpernickel flour have become popular menu items at many bakeries and coffee shops.
But are these trendy baked goods actually a healthy choice for people with diabetes? Let's take a closer look at the nutrition and health effects of pumpernickel bagels.
Nutrition Profile of Pumpernickel Bagels
Like other whole grain foods, pumpernickel bagels provide more fiber and nutrients than refined grain bagels made with white flour. Here is how a 4-inch whole wheat pumpernickel bagel compares nutritionally to a 4-inch plain bagel made with refined wheat:
- Pumpernickel bagel calories: 230
- Plain bagel calories: 245
- Pumpernickel bagel carbohydrates: 46 grams
- Plain bagel carbohydrates: 53 grams
- Pumpernickel bagel fiber: 5 grams
- Plain bagel fiber: 2 grams
- Pumpernickel bagel protein: 10 grams
- Plain bagel protein: 9 grams
As you can see, the pumpernickel bagel has a nutritional advantage over the plain white flour bagel. It has fewer calories and carbs, almost 3 times as much fiber, and a bit more protein.
Benefits of Pumpernickel Bagels for Diabetes
Eating pumpernickel bread and bagels instead of plain white bread products can benefit people with diabetes in several ways:
1. Better blood sugar control
The additional fiber in whole grain pumpernickel slows down digestion, which prevents blood sugar spikes after meals. The magnesium in pumpernickel may also help regulate blood sugar levels.
2. Increased fullness
The fiber in pumpernickel bagels helps promote feelings of fullness and satisfaction after eating. This can prevent overeating and weight gain.
3. Lower cholesterol
Fiber binds to cholesterol in the digestive tract to remove it from the body. Pumpernickel bread is a good source of cholesterol-lowering fiber.
4. Decreased inflammation
Chronic inflammation worsens insulin resistance and contributes to diabetes complications. The antioxidants in whole grains like pumpernickel help reduce inflammation.
Potential Downsides of Pumpernickel Bagels
Despite their perks, there are some potential issues to keep in mind with pumpernickel bagels:
1. Carb content
At about 46 grams of carbs, a 4-inch pumpernickel bagel is still a high carb food. Eating too many could lead to blood sugar spikes. It's best to limit portion sizes to 1/2 or 1/4 of a bagel.
2. High calorie density
Bagels are calorie-dense, meaning they pack a lot of calories in a small serving size. Be mindful of portions to avoid excess calorie intake when eating pumpernickel bagels.
3. Lack of protein
Bagels on their own are not a great source of protein, which helps control blood sugar and keeps you feeling full. Pair pumpernickel bagels with protein foods like eggs, nut butter, or smoked salmon.
4. Sodium content
Like most commercial breads, pumpernickel bagels can be quite high in sodium. This can increase blood pressure. Seek out low-sodium varieties or limit added salt.
Tips for Choosing and Eating Pumpernickel Bagels
If you want to include pumpernickel bagels as part of a diabetes-friendly diet, keep these tips in mind:
- Look for 100% whole grain pumpernickel bagels with at least 3 grams of fiber per serving.
- Check the label and select the lowest sodium option.
- Opt for mini or thin bagels to better control portions and carbs.
- Spread bagels with diabetes-friendly topping like hummus, avocado, nut butter, or ricotta cheese.
- Combine bagels with eggs or Canadian bacon for a balanced breakfast or snack.
- Stick to half or even just 1/4 of a pumpernickel bagel as one serving.
Healthier Bagel Alternatives for Diabetes
In addition to pumpernickel, there are other flavorful whole grain bagel varieties that make smart choices for people with diabetes:
1. Sprouted Grain Bagels
Sprouted grain bagels are made from whole grains that have been allowed to sprout before being milled into flour. This boosts their nutrient content. Look for sprouted whole wheat, rye, or Ezekiel brand bagels.
2. Oat Bran Bagels
For an extra fiber kick, choose bagels made with oat bran. Just check the label to make sure no white flour has been added.
3. Flaxseed Bagels
Bagels studded with nutty flaxseeds offer heart-healthy fats called omega-3s along with fiber, vitamins, and minerals.
4. Whole Grain Gluten-Free Bagels
Those avoiding gluten can find bagels made with whole grains like brown rice, sorghum, or quinoa flour rather than wheat. These offer more nutrition than plain gluten-free bagels.
Healthier Bread Alternatives to Bagels
For people with diabetes, there are also many healthy bread choices beyond bagels:
- Whole grain breads (look for 100% whole wheat or other whole grain as the first ingredient)
- Sprouted breads
- Light or diet rye breads
- Sourdough breads
- Corn tortillas or whole grain wraps
- Gluten-free breads made with whole grains
Swap out plain bagels with some of these flavorful and nutritious alternatives to create healthier sandwiches, toast, and breakfasts.
The Bottom Line
When consumed in moderation as part of a balanced diet and active lifestyle, pumpernickel bagels can be a better choice for people with diabetes than plain refined flour bagels. They provide more fiber, nutrients, and blood sugar controlling benefits.
However, those wanting to maximize the health benefits of their diet may be better off focusing on other whole grain breads and bread alternatives that are lower in carbs and calories than bagels. As with any food, pay attention to portion sizes of bagels and partner them with lean proteins, healthy fats, and vegetables.
By making smart substitutions and keeping overall carbohydrate intake in check, people with diabetes can still enjoy the occasional bagel while managing their blood sugar and health.
FAQs
Are pumpernickel bagels considered a whole grain?
Yes, pumpernickel bagels are made from whole rye grains so they are considered a whole grain food.
Do pumpernickel bagels spike blood sugar?
Pumpernickel bagels have a lower glycemic index than regular white flour bagels, but they can still raise blood sugar levels, especially in large portions. It's best to pair pumpernickel bagels with protein and eat small portions.
Can people with diabetes eat bread?
People with diabetes can eat bread in moderation as part of a healthy diet, but they should choose whole grain, high fiber options like pumpernickel bread and keep portion sizes small.
What is the healthiest bread for diabetics?
Some of the healthiest bread options for diabetics include 100% whole wheat bread, sprouted grain breads, sourdough bread, light rye bread, and corn tortillas.
Are there gluten-free pumpernickel bagels?
Yes, you can find gluten-free pumpernickel bagels made with either all purpose gluten-free flour or gluten-free whole grains like brown rice flour and sorghum flour.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new treatment regimen.
Add Comment