Pizza vs. Burgers: Which One is the Better Choice?
Pizza and burgers are two of the most popular foods worldwide. But in the battle of pizza vs. burgers, which one comes out on top as the healthier and tastier option? There are good arguments on both sides. Here is a detailed comparison of the pros and cons of pizza and burgers to help decide which is ultimately the better choice.
Nutritional Value
At first glance, burgers would seem to have an advantage over pizza when it comes to nutrition. Beef burgers provide protein, iron, zinc and B vitamins. But the type of protein matters - beef provides high amounts of saturated fat compared to leaner options like turkey or veggie burgers. The bun and condiments like cheese and mayo also add calories, fat and carbs.
Pizza offers carbs from the crust, protein from cheese and toppings like pepperoni, and nutrients like antioxidants from tomato sauce. Going light on cheese and meat while piling on veggie toppings can make pizza relatively nutritious. Thin crust pizza is lower carb than thick crust or pan styles.
The verdict: Lean beef or turkey burgers can beat pizza in nutrition, but veggie burgers and veggie loaded pizzas even things out.
Calories
Both pizza and burgers are calorie dense foods, with averages around 300 calories per serving. A basic cheese pizza slice may have 250-300 calories. A fast food burger often exceeds 300 calories, especially with extras like bacon and cheese.
However, gourmet burgers and pizzas can approach 1,000 calories or more per serving depending on toppings and cooking methods. Deep dish pizza and burgers with multiple patties take things to the extreme.
Going with single patty burgers and lighter toppings keeps burgers reasonable. Opting for thin crust pizzas with lots of low-calorie veggie toppings does the same.
The verdict: Pizza and burgers can both range wildly in calories, so smart choices are key for either option.
Fat Content
Along with high calories comes high fat content for most burgers and pizzas. Burgers get most of their fat from the beef patty and cheese toppings. Using leaner cuts of meat and plant-based cheeses can reduce some of that fat.
For pizza, cheese and meat toppings like pepperoni and sausage drive up the saturated fat content. Opting for veggie toppings instead helps lighten the fat load.
Portion control is also key. Eating multiple large slices of even veggie pizza can add up in fat. Sticking to a single burger patty with just one slice of cheese is a leaner approach.
The verdict: Burgers made with lean beef or turkey and light cheese are lower fat than meat-heavy pizza.
Carbohydrates
Pizza has the advantage when it comes to carbs, thanks to the crust. An average slice of plain cheese pizza provides 15-20 grams of carbs from the dough. Add in other carb-heavy toppings like pineapple, and the numbers climb higher.
Burgers don't have much in the way of carbs beyond the bun, contributing around 15 grams of carbs. Loading up a burger with extra buns or fries quickly increases carb counts.
Those on low-carb diets can opt for lettuce wrap burgers or cauliflower crust pizzas to slash carb content. Overall though, burgers have a little less carb impact than pizza.
The verdict: Burgers have fewer carbs and are a better choice for low-carb lifestyles.
Fiber Content
Fiber is an area where pizza has a clear advantage over burgers. An average pizza crust supplies a gram or two of dietary fiber. Add fiber-rich veggie toppings like mushrooms, onions, and peppers, and the numbers grow.
Burgers don't provide much fiber beyond the bun. Adding lettuce and tomato bumps up the fiber content a bit, but even veggie burgers likely don't match the fiber found in veggie pizzas.
The verdict: Pizza wins when it comes to providing filling fiber.
Protein Content
Burgers win when comparing protein sources. A beef burger patty provides around 15-20 grams of protein pre-cooked. Other patty options like turkey and veggie also provide protein.
Cheese pizza has about 15 grams of protein per slice, mostly from cheese. Adding meats like sausage or chicken can boost pizza protein a bit more.
The verdict: Burgers deliver more protein, especially when using meat-based patties.
Food Customization
One of pizza's winning qualities is the ability to customize it with endless topping possibilities. Veggie lovers can pile on onions, mushrooms, peppers, spinach, and more.
For meat lovers, options like pepperoni, sausage, bacon, ground beef and other proteins allow perfect customization. White pizza, Hawaiian, BBQ chicken - the varieties are endless.
Burgers also can be customized but options are generally more limited. The patty, cheese, bun and basic toppings like lettuce, tomato and onion are staples. Still, burger menus offer options.
The verdict: Pizza is the winner when it comes to fully customizing a main dish.
Cooking Convenience
Burgers are quicker and easier for home cooking. Just heat up a skillet and fry the patties for a few minutes on each side. Assembling burger toppings takes just minutes too.
Homemade pizza requires kneading dough and letting it proof. Topping and baking the pie takes 30 minutes or more. Frozen pizza avoids much of this work but sacrifices freshness.
The verdict: Burgers are faster and more convenient for home cooking.
Kid Friendliness
Both pizza and burgers are loved by kids and adults alike. Pizza wins points for customization - picky eaters can stick to cheese while adventures eaters can add any toppings.
Burgers are simple and familiar. Some kids strongly prefer burgers to pizza or vice versa based on habit and taste.
Since most kids love both burgers and pizza, it's hard to pick a winner. But pizza offers more variety to please different preferences.
The verdict: Both score highly, but pizza takes the edge for kid friendliness.
The Final Verdict
Based on total health impact, nutrition profile, degree of customization and kid appeal, pizza edges out burgers in this food face-off. Burgers win points for convenience and protein content. But pizza comes out as the overall better meal.
With smart modifications like veggie toppings and reasonable portion sizes, pizza can be a nutritional winner. Burgers will always have devotees. But pizza seems to have broader appeal and advantages.
In the end, both foods can have a place in an overall healthy lifestyle. But when craving just one, pizza is the better choice for most people.
FAQs
Is pizza healthier than burgers?
Pizza can be healthier than burgers when you opt for thin crust and pile on veggie toppings while limiting cheese and meat. This results in fewer calories, less fat, and more fiber than a typical burger.
Do burgers or pizza have more protein?
Burgers generally provide more protein than pizza. A beef burger may have 15-20 grams of protein while a veggie pizza slice has around 15 grams, mostly from the cheese.
Which has less carbs, pizza or burgers?
Burgers contain fewer carbs than pizza since they don't have a crust. The burger bun has around 15 grams of carbs versus 30+ grams of carbs for a thick pizza crust.
Can you make both pizza and burgers healthy?
Yes, both burgers and pizza can be made healthier. Choosing lean meat or veggie burgers, whole grain buns, and veggie toppings keeps burgers reasonable. Using thin crust, no-sugar sauce, and hitting the veggie toppings makes pizza better.
Why do many people prefer pizza over burgers?
Reasons people may prefer pizza include the variety of toppings, customizable options even for picky eaters, appeal to vegetarians, and the generally more favorable nutrition profile compared to burgers.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new treatment regimen.
Add Comment