When to See a Psychiatrist vs. Therapist
Mental health treatment often involves working with specialists like psychiatrists and therapists. While both provide care for mental health conditions, there are important differences in their roles, expertise, and treatment methods. Understanding those differences can help you determine which type of mental health professional is the best fit for your needs.
What is a Psychiatrist?
A psychiatrist is a medical doctor who specializes in diagnosing and treating mental illnesses and disorders. After earning a medical degree, psychiatrists complete additional specialized training in the form of a psychiatry residency program. This intensive 4-year program teaches psychiatrists to evaluate and treat mental health conditions through methods like medication management and psychotherapy.
As medical doctors, psychiatrists can prescribe medication and have an advanced understanding of how medications work in the brain and body. Psychiatrists often focus heavily on using psychotropic medications as a tool to treat mental illness. Some common medications prescribed by psychiatrists include:
- Antidepressants
- Anti-anxiety medications
- Mood stabilizers
- Stimulants
- Antipsychotics
In addition to medications, psychiatrists are also trained in different types of psychotherapy and counseling to help patients develop coping strategies for their mental health condition. However, psychiatrists tend to spend less time providing therapy compared to other mental health professionals.
When to See a Psychiatrist
Here are some of the main reasons you may want to see a psychiatrist for mental health treatment:
- To get an official diagnosis - As medical doctors, psychiatrists can give a clinical diagnosis of a mental health disorder based on a thorough evaluation.
- To determine if medication is needed - Only psychiatrists (and nurse practitioners in some states) can prescribe psychiatric medications, such as antidepressants.
- To monitor medication treatment - Psychiatrists can monitor how medication is working and make adjustments to maximize benefits.
- For severe or complex conditions - Psychiatrists have expertise treating severe disorders like schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, OCD, and addiction.
- Co-occurring physical illness - Psychiatrists can address the interplay between mental illness and other medical conditions.
Keep in mind that a psychiatrist may still involve other mental health professionals like therapists or counselors in your treatment. An integrated care approach often yields the best results.
What is a Therapist or Counselor?
There are many different types of therapists and counselors who provide mental health treatment without prescribing medication. Some common titles include:
- Psychologists
- Psychotherapists
- Clinical social workers
- Marriage and family therapists
- Mental health counselors
These professionals complete graduate training in psychology-related fields to obtain a Master's or Doctoral degree. Therapists and counselors utilize verbal psychotherapy as the main treatment approach. There are many forms of talk therapy they may use including:
- Cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT)
- Dialectical behavior therapy (DBT)
- Exposure therapy
- Psychodynamic therapy
- Group therapy
- Couples counseling
- Family therapy
The goal of therapy is to help clients develop healthier thought patterns and coping mechanisms for dealing with their mental health issues. Therapists build a therapeutic alliance with their clients and provide a judgement-free space to work through challenges.
When to See a Therapist or Counselor
Seeing a therapist or counselor may be preferred in these situations:
- For talk therapy/counseling - To develop skills to cope with challenges through weekly therapy sessions.
- Mild to moderate disorders - Many common conditions like anxiety, depression, PTSD respond well to counseling.
- Relationship issues - Marriage counseling and family therapy can help resolve conflicts.
- No medication needed - If you want to take a non-drug approach and try therapy first.
- Daily functioning - Improve skills like stress management, communication, mindfulness.
Therapists and counselors may also play a role in treatment after an initial psychiatric evaluation. The two professions can work together as part of a coordinated treatment plan.
Key Differences Between Psychiatrists and Therapists
Although both provide mental health care, there are some notable ways psychiatrists and therapists differ:
Psychiatrist
- Role: Medical doctor who diagnoses and treats mental illness
- Training: Medical degree + residency in psychiatry
- Approach: Medication management, psychotherapy, diagnostic testing
- Expertise: Evaluating and prescribing medication for psychiatric disorders
- Appointments: 15-30 minute medication management appointments
Therapist/Counselor
- Role: Provide ongoing talk therapy and counseling
- Training: Master's or Doctoral degree in psychology or counseling
- Approach: Weekly counseling and psychotherapy sessions
- Expertise: Treating issues through therapeutic techniques and strategies
- Appointments: 45-60 minute counseling sessions
Finding a Psychiatrist vs. Therapist
Use this checklist when searching for a psychiatrist or therapist/counselor:
Psychiatrist Checklist
- Board certified in psychiatry
- Accepts your insurance coverage
- Has experience treating your condition
- You feel comfortable speaking with them
- Offers convenient office hours and location
Search online directories or ask your primary care doctor for psychiatrist referrals. Review qualifications, treatment approaches, accepted insurance, and patient reviews.
Therapist/Counselor Checklist
- Licensed in your state
- Accepts your insurance or offers affordable rates
- Uses proven therapies for your needs
- Focuses on issues you want to address
- Connects well with you personally
Search through online counselor directories like Psychology Today or GoodTherapy and filter by factors like specialty, techniques, and insurance coverage.
Integrated Care for Optimal Mental Health
The best approach for mental health often combines both medication and psychotherapy. Seeing both a psychiatrist and therapist allows you to benefit from the expertise of both professions and gain more comprehensive care.
Your psychiatrist can handle diagnosing and medication needs, while regularly communicating with your therapist. Meanwhile, your therapist can provide critical counseling to help you develop coping strategies. Together, they ensure your mental health is supported through multiple treatment modalities.
By understanding the roles of psychiatrists vs. therapists, you can determine which type of mental health professional is the right fit your current situation and recovery goals.
FAQs
Can a therapist prescribe medication?
No, therapists cannot prescribe medication - only psychiatrists and certain other medical doctors can prescribe psychiatric medications. Therapists provide counseling and therapy only.
Should I see a psychiatrist or therapist first?
If you need medication, see a psychiatrist first for an evaluation and prescription. If you want to start with therapy only, see a therapist first. A psychiatrist may refer you to a therapist, and vice versa.
How much does therapy vs. psychiatry cost?
On average, psychiatry appointments cost $150-300 per session without insurance. Therapy costs $60-150 per session on average. With good health insurance, copays are usually lower for both.
How often should I see a psychiatrist vs. therapist?
Psychiatry visits are much less frequent - usually every 1-3 months for 15-30 minutes to check on medications. Therapy is weekly or biweekly for 45-60 minute sessions to work on talk therapy.
What’s the difference in training?
Psychiatrists complete medical school plus a 4 year psychiatry residency. Therapists have a Master's or Doctoral degree in psychology or counseling, but no medical degree.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new treatment regimen.
Add Comment