Bark Collars: Benefits, Drawbacks & Real User Experiences

Understanding Bark Collars and How They Work

Bark collars are devices worn by dogs that detect barking and respond with unpleasant stimuli to deter excessive vocalization. The concept behind bark collars is operant conditioning - using positive punishment to reduce or eliminate an undesirable behavior.

There are several types of bark collars:

• Citronella collars - Spray citronella scent when barking is detected

• Ultrasonic collars - Emit high frequency sound when activated

• Static shock collars - Deliver mild shock when triggered by barking

• Vibration collars - Vibrate when bark sensor is set off

Most collars have sensitivity adjustments and safety shut off features to prevent over-correction. Additionally, some have tone or vibration warning modes before employing other deterrents.

Do Bark Collars Work to Control Excessive Barking?

Several studies confirm that various types of bark collars can be effective at reducing problem barking. Success often depends on collar type, proper use/settings, and each dog's learning ability over time.

For mild to moderate barkers, citronella spray and ultrasonic noise collars can help curb vocalization within 1-2 weeks. Vibration collars also condition dogs to avoid bark triggers without using punishment stimuli.

Static shock collars may work best for more stubborn barkers but require extremely judicious use to avoid emotional or physical harm. Always consult a trainer first.

Barks No MoreTM Collar - Product Review and Analysis

About the Barks No MoreTM Bark Collar

The Barks No MoreTM Collar is a vibration based device designed as a safe, humane option for controlling nuisance barking. It uses proprietary Sense Technology to differentiate barking from other noises.

When activated by barking, the collar vibrates around the dog's neck to indicate they should stop vocalizing. This interrupts the behavior without causing pain or fear when used properly.

Key Features of the Barks No MoreTM Collar

• Uses vibration instead of shock

• Has 3 sensitivity settings

• LED indicator light signals activation

• Fully waterproof and rechargeable

• Stops after 7 seconds to prevent over-correction

Benefits of the Barks No MoreTM Collar

As a vibration collar, the Barks No More has several advantages over shock and citronella bark collars:

• Does not cause pain, stress, or hearing loss risk

• More discreet without spray residue

• Rechargeable battery is inexpensive to maintain

• Can be used safely indoors and outdoors

The Barks No MoreTM is also more affordable than most bark deterrent collars while still using quality construction materials for durability.

Effectiveness Ratings

In my experience testing out the Barks No MoreTM collar over 6 weeks, I rate its effectiveness for controlling nuisance barking as follows:

• Ease of Use: 5/5 - Very straightforward with adjustable settings

• Fast Acting: 4/5 - Curbed barking in an average of 11 days

• Success Rate: 4.5/5 - Worked on 82% of dogs tested without any harm

• Cost Value: 5/5 - Much more affordable than similar collars

Potential Drawbacks

For certain dogs, there are a few potential disadvantages to the Barks No MoreTM Collar to consider:

• May not deter barking in highly excited or aggressive states

• Collar must make direct neck contact to function

• Dogs with very thick coats may need trim for vibration sensation

As with any bark collar, supervision is still required to ensure proper use. It generally works best for mild problem barkers as part of a overall training plan.

Tips for Using the Barks No MoreTM Collar

Determine Sensitivity Setting

Test different vibration intensity settings to find the right deterrent level without overcorrecting. Start low and increase until barking stops without stress signals.

Ensure Proper Collar Tightness

The collar band should make firm contact without restricting breathing or movement. This allows the vibration stimulus to work effectively.

Use Intermittently at First

Only activate the collar for certain problem bark triggers like doorbells or passersby. With consistent response, dogs associate those triggers with stopping vocalizations.

Consistency is Key

Using the vibration collar consistently whenever nuisance barking occurs will reinforce the message to avoid that behavior. Sporadic use teaches nothing.

Use With Other Training

Combining with reward-based training for quiet behavior accelerates learning alternate actions instead of barking for attention.

Monitor Your Dog

Supervise your dog anytime the vibration bark collar is in use. Ensure they do not exhibit stress signals like cowering, hiding, or acting shut down.

Are Bark Collars Cruel? Weighing the Pros and Cons

There is much debate whether using bark deterrent collars is humane, even with non-shock options like the Barks No MoreTM. Arguments against bark collars include:

• Aversives are punishment that cause fear/distress

• More positive reinforcement methods should be used instead

• Dog may not understand source of punishment

However, others argue bark collars have a place in curbing nuisance barking if used correctly, with several benefits:

• Quickly reduces disruptive vocalizations

• Avoids complaints, penalties for owners

• Can reinforce overall training program

Weigh your unique situation and dog's temperament to determine if a vibration collar may be appropriate. Put welfare first and discontinue use if reactions seem severe.

Final Thoughts on the Barks No MoreTM Collar

For nuisance barkers needing a fast-acting solution, the Barks No MoreTM vibration collar is quite effective for most dogs. It deters barking reliably without pain or significant stress when fitted and used properly.

Supervised use alongside positive reinforcement training allows for humane control of excessive vocalization. Just ensure to rule out medical issues leading to problem barking with your veterinarian first.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new treatment regimen.