Aligners vs Braces: An In-Depth Comparison
Getting straighter teeth is a goal for many people, but deciding between orthodontic treatment options like aligners and braces can be difficult. Both can effectively straighten teeth, but have different pros and cons.
Clear aligners like Invisalign are a popular alternative to traditional metal braces. Aligners use a series of clear plastic trays that are worn sequentially to gradually move teeth into place. Braces use brackets and wires to apply constant pressure to teeth to straighten them.
When comparing aligners vs braces, there are a number of factors to consider including treatment process, comfort, appearance, effectiveness, cost, and more. Read on for an in-depth comparison of aligners and braces to help you decide which is the best option for straighter teeth.
Aligner Treatment Process
The aligner treatment process involves the following steps:
- Impressions and photos are taken of your teeth
- These are used to create a customized treatment plan and 3D image of your teeth moving
- A series of BPA-free clear plastic aligners are made for your treatment plan
- Aligners are worn in sets for 1-2 weeks before switching to the next set in the series
- Most treatment plans span 18-24 months on average
- Youll visit your orthodontist periodically for check-ups and new aligners
With aligners, teeth are moved incrementally into place. Each set gently moves your teeth until the desired position is reached. Treatment time depends on the complexity of your case.
Braces Treatment Process
Getting braces involves the following steps:
- Metal or ceramic brackets are bonded to your teeth
- Orthodontic wires are threaded through the brackets
- Elastic bands may be used to attach the wire to the brackets
- The wires apply constant pressure to move teeth into place
- The orthodontist periodically tightens wires and adjusts braces
- Treatment times range from 12-24 months on average
- Braces are removed once desired results are achieved
Braces apply steady pressure to teeth to straighten them. With braces, the teeth are moved more immediately into the desired positions.
Comfort and Convenience
Clear aligner treatments like Invisalign are often considered more comfortable and convenient than traditional braces.
Aligners pros:
- Aligners are removable for eating, brushing and flossing
- No food restrictions since you take aligners out to eat
- Less abrasive on cheeks and gums than braces
- No metal brackets or wires to cause irritation
- Aligners are smooth and comfortable
- Treatment requires fewer in-office visits
Braces cons:
- Braces cannot be removed
- Foods must be avoided to prevent damage
- Braces rub and can scrape the inside of the mouth
- Brackets and wires cause irritation
- More frequent orthodontist visits needed
Since aligners are removable, they provide more freedom and flexibility. You can remove them for important events or photos. However, aligners must be worn 20-22 hours a day to be effective.
Appearance
Appearance is a major consideration when choosing between aligners and braces.
Aligners pros:
- Aligners are nearly invisible
- Most people won't realize you're straightening your teeth
- Subtle appearance for professional settings
- Clear aligner brands like Invisalign are popular for discreet straightening
Braces cons:
- Braces are highly visible with metal brackets and wires
- Ceramic braces are less noticeable but still visible
- Obvious you are undergoing orthodontic treatment
- Can impact professional settings or photos
If highest discretion in appearance matters most, then clear aligners offer a subtler straightening solution. Those who don't mind the braces look may appreciate how quickly braces straighten teeth.
Effectiveness
Aligners and braces are both highly effective at straightening teeth and producing a great smile. However, there are some differences when it comes to what they can treat.
Aligners pros:
- Effective for mild to moderate alignment issues
- Straighten crooked or gapped teeth
- Improve overbites, underbites and crossbites
- Good option for adults and teens
Braces pros:
- Effective for moderate to complex cases
- Treat more severe misalignments
- Rotate teeth that severely protrude
- Close extra wide gaps between teeth
- Often the best treatment for children
While less suitable for complex cases, aligners can treat mild to moderate issues extremely well. Braces have greater ability to treat severe tooth misalignment.
Treatment Time
Treatment time is similar for both options, ranging from 12-24 months on average depending on severity of your case.
Some key differences that impact treatment time are:
- Aligners move teeth incrementally while braces apply constant pressure
- Simple cases may be slightly faster with braces
- More complex cases can require shorter treatment with braces
- Teens may see faster progress with braces as teeth move quicker
- Alignment issues that require attachment use (like rubber bands) move faster with braces
While braces may have a slight edge for speed, treatment times are relatively comparable between the two options.
Lifestyle Impact
Aligners offer more flexibility and freedom for an active lifestyle. Braces have more diet and activity restrictions.
Aligners pros:
- Can be removed for sports and athletic activities
- No dietary restrictions since aligners are removable
- Can be taken out for playing musical instruments and singing
- Allow you to more easily maintain your routine and habits
Braces cons:
- Certain foods must be avoided to prevent damage
- Oral activities like playing instruments can be impacted
- Athletic mouthguards must be worn for sports
- Braces hooks can be damaged if proper care isn't taken
Aligners allow you to keep your regular habits and behaviors while straightening your teeth.
Cost and Payment Plans
Aligners generally cost more for treatment than braces:
- Aligners average $3,000-$8,000 compared to $3,000-$7,000 for braces
- However, many orthodontists offer payment plans for both
- Treatment under dental insurance can lower out-of-pocket expense
- Options like dental schools and orthodontic schools also provide lower cost care
When reviewing the overall investment for treatment, make sure to consider available financing and insurance coverage to help budget for orthodontic work.
Maintenance
Good oral hygiene is critical during treatment with both aligners and braces.
Aligners require:
- Brushing after each time you eat before reinserting aligners
- Regular flossing to avoid cavities between teeth
- Cleaning aligners daily to prevent bacteria buildup
- Avoiding staining foods and drinks while wearing aligners
Braces require:
- Thorough brushing and flossing to prevent tooth decay
- Dental wax and orthodontic relief if brackets rub
- Avoiding sticky, hard, and crunchy foods
- Using recommended oral hygiene tools
Proper aligner and braces care is needed to maintain treatment progress and oral health.
Invisalign: The Top Clear Aligner System
Invisalign is the most popular and well-known clear aligner system. Heres an overview of how Invisalign works:
- Starts with Invisaligns 3D digital scanning technology to map your teeth
- Custom aligners are created from BPA-free plastic that are nearly invisible
- Aligners are delivered in advance for the full treatment timeline
- Each set is worn for 1-2 weeks for 20-22 hours per day
- Teeth gradually move into place until you achieve the desired result
- Average treatment is 12 months but depends on case complexity
Invisalign is used to treat issues like:
- Crowding
- Spacing
- Overbite
- Underbite
- Crossbite
- Open bite
- Gaps between teeth
- Deep bite
Benefits of Invisalign include:
- Comfortable, smooth plastic aligners are easy to adapt to
- Treatment times comparable to braces
- Aligners are removable for flexibility in eating and hygiene
- Virtually invisible so most people wont detect them
- Allows you to continue your normal activities and routines
- No injuries from broken wires or brackets
- Less adjustment visits needed with the orthodontist
While more expensive than braces, Invisalign offers an effective and discreet way to straighten your teeth.
Finding the Right Orthodontist
Choosing the right orthodontist for aligners or braces is key for a successful treatment experience. Here are tips for finding a skilled orthodontist:
- Ask people you trust like your dentist for recommendations of the top local orthodontists
- Look for an orthodontist who is certified in the latest techniques and equipment
- Search online reviews for orthodontists who have consistently positive ratings and feedback
- Schedule consultations with potential orthodontists to get a feel for their approach, bedside manner and how thorough they are
- Look for an orthodontist who explains all your options and listens to your goals for your teeth
- Consider convenience factors like office location and appointment availability
- Discuss payment, insurance coverage and financing options the orthodontist offers
- Choose an orthodontist who makes you feel comfortable and addresses all your questions
Taking the time to pick the best orthodontist for your needs and preferences will set you up for orthodontic success.
Achieving Your Best Smile
While both offer tremendous benefits, aligners and braces cater to different patient needs and preferences. As you make your decision, focus on your specific orthodontic goals, lifestyle, budget and personal priorities. This will help guide you to the best solution for your smile.
With advances in modern orthodontics, achieving your dream smile is more possible than ever. Taking the first step to book a consultation is the initial move to straighter, healthier aligned teeth that boost your confidence.
FAQs
How long does treatment take with aligners vs braces?
Treatment time is similar for both aligners and braces, ranging from 12-24 months depending on the severity of your case. However, braces may have a slight edge for speed with more complex cases or for teens since teeth move quicker.
Can aligners treat severe cases as well as braces?
Aligners work extremely well for mild to moderate orthodontic cases. However, people with severe misalignments, crooked teeth or abnormal bites often achieve better results faster with traditional braces.
Do aligners hurt?
Aligners typically do not hurt. Most people feel pressure and tightness as teeth are moving with each new set of aligners. This dissipates in 3-5 days as you get used to the new aligner. Aligners tend to be more comfortable than braces.
Can I play sports while wearing aligners?
Yes, aligners are removable so you can take them out for athletic activities. However, a mouthguard is still recommended to protect teeth from injury or damage.
How much more do invisalign aligners cost vs. braces?
Aligners average $3,000-$8,000 for treatment while braces range from $3,000-$7,000 on average. Aligners typically cost more compared to braces, but check with your orthodontist for specific pricing.
Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice. Always consult with a healthcare professional before starting any new treatment regimen.
Add Comment